Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
           06 December, 2022

Category:  Press » Legal


Chevron Suffers Major Legal Setback as U.S. Court Throws Out Fraud Claims, Rejects Motion to Attach Assets, Says Amazon Defense Coalition Source: PR Newswire

         Views: 2465
2012-05-15 05:08:56     
Amazon Defense Coalition

NEW YORK, May 14, 2012 -- Chevron suffered two new legal setbacks today when a U.S. federal judge, who usually favors the company, rejected its attempt to attach the assets of the Ecuadorians and their counsel who won an $18 billion judgment for environmental damage and separately tossed out two fraud-related claims against an American lawyer, according to published court decisions.
Judge Lewis A. Kaplan -- who for the last two years has almost uniformly favored Chevron in the hotly contested case -- also cast doubt on the viability of Chevron's two remaining claims under the federal civil racketeering statute, dealing another blow to the oil giant's campaign to evade paying the landmark judgment that was issued in February of 2011.
The decisions are the latest in a series of legal setbacks this year against Chevron over the $18 billion judgment. They include the unanimous reversal of Kaplan in a U.S. federal appeals court of a worldwide injunction against enforcement of the Ecuadorian judgment; an Ecuadorian appellate court's confirmation of a trial court decision that Chevron dumped billions of gallons of toxic waste into Ecuador's Amazon; and now, a refusal to attach the assets of the Ecuadorians and a narrowing of the fraud case.
Kaplan also cast doubt on the remaining RICO claims, saying they "raised a question concerning whether and to what extent Chevron may recover ... for injuries sustained" outside of the United States.
"Suffice it to say for present purposes that Chevron on the present record has not established that it is likely to prevail on its claim" that funds spent to defend the case in Ecuador would be recoverable in the fraud case, essentially eviscerating the company's ability to recover damages, according to the court.
In making his rulings on a pre-trial motion to dismiss the fraud case, Kaplan was required by law to assume that all facts alleged by Chevron were true even though they are contested by the rainforest communities and their counsel, who allege that Chevron committed criminal acts and fraud to cover up its extensive contamination in the South American nation.
Yet even with the assumption its disputed allegations were true, Chevron still found two of its claims tossed out and was soundly rebuked by Kaplan on the attachment issue, said Karen Hinton, the U.S. spokesperson for the Ecuadorians. At this point, Chevron is the only party in the litigation facing attachment of its assets given that the Ecuador judgment is enforceable around the world, Hinton added.
"These rulings by Judge Kaplan are yet another devastating setback for Chevron's prospects to avoid paying the Ecuador judgment," said Hinton. "The fact Chevron is now running into resistance from its most favored U.S. federal judge shows just how dim the company's legal outlook has become on the Ecuador case."
"Chevron has suffered a virtually uninterrupted string of defeats in courts in Ecuador and the United States over the past year and we expect this trend to continue in the coming months in courts around the world," Hinton added.
Hinton added in a prepared statement:
"Judge Kaplan's decisions to deny Chevron attachment and to throw out several fraud claims represent yet another setback for the oil company and its shareholders. In the last year, Chevron has seen courts in Ecuador and the U.S. vacate its worldwide injunction against enforcement of the Ecuador judgment; affirm the Ecuador trial court judgment; reject an international investor arbitration attempt to block the Ecuador trial; deny a motion to attach the assets of the Ecuadorian rainforest communities; and throw out a good portion of its fraud case against the Ecuadorians and their American lawyers. Given that it still refuses to pay the Ecuador judgment, it is Chevron that now faces attachment actions against billions of dollars of company assets in courts around the world for intentionally polluting the Ecuadorian rainforest.
"That said, Chevron's RICO charges always have been baseless and are nothing more than a public relations stunt to hide the company's environmental abuses and fraud in Ecuador that destroyed the rainforest and killed numerous people with cancer and other oil-related diseases. If the RICO case proceeds to trial, which is highly doubtful in light of today's ruling, the rainforest communities and their counsel plan to file counterclaims against Chevron and certain of its executives for fraud and are confident that the case will result in a finding of additional liability against individuals in Chevron who are responsible for the environmental disaster and cover-up."

Specialized in: Karen Hinton - Amazon Defense Coalition - Fraud Claims - Rejects Motion
Print press release      Bookmark this page
Related Press releases 
Construction Dispute Resolution Company "Contract Dispute Solutions" Launch Partnership Programme (Popularity: ): The construction and development sector of the UK and Global economy offers high value earning market opportunities in terms of both dispute resolution and dispute avoidance but many organisations are not positioned to maximise the opportunities.The main advantages of creating a strategic partnership with Contract Dispute Solutions www.contractdisputesolutions.co.uk include:•Added service provision to satisfy client's objectives. •Little, if any, investment risk. •Little, if any, overheads. •Client Base protected. •Construction and development ...
Time for International Community to Act on Thai Political Crisis, Says Thaksin Lawyer (Popularity: ): Robert Amsterdam, a lawyer acting on behalf of the former Prime Minister of Thailand Thaksin Shinawatra, calls upon the international community to respond to the Thai government's violent crackdown on protestors in Bangkok.According to recent media reports, at least 17 people are confirmed dead and 140 injured, many seriously, after the Thai military opened fire with live ammunition on red shirt protesters in the centre of Bangkok yesterday. Three foreigners ...
Justice Department and FBI Announce Formal Conclusion of Investigation into 2001 Anthrax Attacks (Popularity: ): The Justice Department, FBI and U.S. Postal Inspection Service today announced that the investigation into the 2001 anthrax attacks, which killed five individuals and sickened 17 others, has formally concluded.Earlier today, representatives of the FBI and Justice Department provided a 92-page investigative summary along with attachments to victims of the attacks, relatives of the victims and appropriate committees of Congress. This document sets forth a summary of the evidence developed ...
Criminal Record Inc. Announces Fastest and Most In-Depth Criminal Records System Available (Popularity: ): Today Criminal Record has announced the deployment of powerful new programming, databases and hardware that make conducting a criminal records search anywhere in the United States a much more accurate and painless process.For years conducting background checks has been problematic in the sense that not every record was covered and quality of data varied greatly in quality plus scope from company to company.The new system announced by Criminal Record today ...
Law Enforcement Officer Fatalities Fall Sharply during Third Quarter of 2009 (Popularity: ): After jumping 20 percent in the first six months of 2009, the number of law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty fell sharply during the third quarter of this year and is on pace to reach a five-decade low this year, according to preliminary data from the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund.Nationwide, 26 officers died in the line of duty during the months of July, August and ...

Related Business 
National Organization of Veterans' Advocates (NOVA) (Popularity: ): Provides legal representation to American veterans and their dependents at the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. Site includes overview of the claims process, membership information, legislative updates and court decisions, amicus activity, and description of services.
Emirates Newswire (Popularity: ): Emirates Newswire is the leading source of latest news & press releases from UAE and MENA region, covering business & finance and tech news. The vision of Emirates Newswire initiate is to become the leading source of news from the corporate sector of UAE and MENA region.
Legal Costs Consultants and Costing Services (Popularity: ): Pattison Hardman has been the recognized leader in legal costing services, legal rights and legal costs consultants in Sydney, NSW. We believe in providing quality legal costing services.Pattison Hardman has been retained to advise on multi-party, multi-cost orders and matters in the High Court of Australia, Federal Court of Australia, Administrative Appeals Tribunal, Family Court, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Land & Environment Court, District Court of New South ...
Criminal Defense Law Firms (Popularity: ): Our Criminal Defense Law Firms have represented thousands of individuals singled out during criminal investigations and charged with all levels of crimes. They have appeared in county court, circuit court, the Florida Supreme Court, and Federal Court to fight for our clients.
Unger & Hershkowitz, Attorneys At Law (Popularity: ): Unger & Hershkowitz is a full-service legal firm located in Houston Texas. We provide services to individual and business clients for a broad range of legal matters. From Criminal Defense to CPS Defense to Employment Law to Legal Malpractice. With over forty years of combined legal experience, our law firm believes that quality representation should be available to everyone. An attorney should be proactive to help clients stay out of ...
Legal Document Centre (Popularity: ): Net Lawman is premier source of online legal documents, document drafting and legal information in UK and other countries. Get comprehensive details for UK acts and country court list.
Law Enforcement Legal Defense Fund (Popularity: ): The Law Enforcement Legal Defense Fund is a non-profit organization providing assistance to law enforcement officers who are required to defend their official actions in court. LELDF provides assistance without regard to race, color, creed, religion or ethnic background.
Inadequate accident claims while training (Popularity: ): Work accident claims solicitors are one of the leading legal firms in the UK covers all type of major Inadequate training accident claims.
USA - - Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (Popularity: ): Non-profit organization dedicated to fighting insurance fraud.
Taxpayers Against Fraud (Popularity: ): A public interest non-profit organization dedicated to combating fraud against the federal government through the promotion and use of the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act.