Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
           24 November, 2020

Category:  Press » Transportation


Controversial DM&E Rail Expansion Proposal Prompts Nation's Top Transportation Official to Visit Rochester

         Views: 1422
2006-12-04 21:24:33     
Rochester Coalition

New U.S. Secretary of Transportation Mary Peters, the nation's top transportation official, traveled to Rochester today in response to a growing controversy over the Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad's (DM&E) proposed rail expansion project and its request for an unprecedented $2.3 billion government loan. Peters met with officials from the Rochester Coalition to hear concerns about the project, which could result in more than 34 mile-long, high-speed trains traveling through downtown Rochester every day, carrying coal and hazardous materials just a few hundred feet from the Mayo Clinic, through the heart of downtown Rochester.

DM&E has the worst safety record in its class of railroad and an accident rate 7.5 times the industry average. Two weeks ago a DM&E derailment outside of New Ulm, Minn., spilled more than 30,000 gallons of ethanol and forced the evacuation of several homes. That same accident in Rochester could have resulted in the need to evacuate a significant portion of the city -- including Mayo Clinic.

In addition to safety concerns, DM&E's $2.3 billion taxpayer-backed loan, the largest loan in U.S. history to a private company, has caught the attention of the nation's leading taxpayer groups, which have joined the Rochester Coalition in calling for the loan to be rejected. Despite the unprecedented use of tax dollars, the DM&E proposal has not been subject to Congressional oversight or a single public hearing. DM&E's entire proposal is being kept confidential and so are the company's investors.

"We thank Secretary Peters for coming to Rochester to see first-hand the threat the DM&E proposal, as it currently stands, poses to our community, the state of Minnesota and the U.S. taxpayer," said Chris Gade, spokesperson for the Rochester Coalition. "The direct involvement of the nation's top transportation official is very encouraging and a sign that this project may get the level of scrutiny it deserves. The people of Rochester and all U.S. taxpayers deserve no less."

While insisting the best mitigation for Rochester is for the loan to be rejected, members of the Rochester Coalition expressed to Peters a willingness to discuss other solutions provided they reflect good public policy, meet the needs of Rochester and Mayo Clinic, and are made a condition of the loan.

"Until Rochester is adequately protected, we will adamantly oppose the loan," added Gade. "If the railroad is looking for the taxpayers to fund its expansion, it should be bending over backwards to ensure those very same taxpayers are adequately protected from disaster and are fully informed about its financing plan and ownership."

The coalition also presented Peters with a new report analyzing DM&E's safety performance on new tracks. The report contradicts the railroad's contention that new tracks will result in a safer railroad.

The key findings of the report, based on an analysis of Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) records, include:

Derailment numbers on new and improved track

* 2004: 3 out of 37 (8 percent)

* 2005: 12 of 28 (42 percent)

* 2006: 8 of 17 (six month) (47 percent)

DM&E's worst accident in its history took place on new tracks in 2004 when 14 rail cars derailed in Balaton, Minn., spilling 60,000 gallons of flammable fuel and forcing the evacuation of local residents. DM&E had just replaced the tracks using an earlier $233 million federal loan.

Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, Sen. Norm Coleman (R-MN) and Congressman- elect Tim Walz (D-MN) also attended the meeting. Coleman recently announced, "If there isn't a plan, then I'll do everything in my prerogatives as senator to stop this project, either through the appropriation process or the legislation process." Walz was a vocal critic of the DM&E loan during his campaign and lists protecting Rochester and Mayo Clinic among his top priorities in Congress.


The Dakota, Minnesota and Eastern Railroad (DM&E) is seeking the largest federal loan to a private company in American history -- a $2.3 billion subsidy from U.S. taxpayers to finance a major rail expansion project through the Midwest. The loan far exceeds the famous Chrysler bailout, which was debated vigorously in the halls of Congress and by the American people. The proposed $2.3 billion taxpayer loan to DM&E has not been subject to a single minute of debate in Congress, and the public has been barred from examining details of the loan application and the company's finances.

According to the New York Times ("Lobbyist Turns Senator But Twists Same Arms," Feb. 28, 2006), DM&E's loan was made possible in 2005 when Sen. John Thune, a former DM&E lobbyist, championed legislation to increase the Federal Railroad Administration's loan program from $3.5 billion to $35 billion and modified the loan criteria to benefit his former employer.

A recent poll, conducted by KRC Research, showed that a majority of registered voters in Minnesota's First Congressional District and more than two-thirds of Rochester residents oppose the DM&E's request for the $2.3 billion federal loan. The same poll conducted statewide in South Dakota found a plurality of residents also opposes the railroad's loan request.

The Rochester Coalition represents the city of Rochester, Minn., Olmsted County, the Rochester Area Chamber of Commerce and Mayo Clinic. The coalition opposes DM&E's $2.3 billion federal loan and the railroad's efforts to expand its rail line through Rochester. DM&E, which according to government statistics has the worst safety record in its class, currently operates three to four slow-moving trains carrying mostly grain products each day through Rochester. The federal loan would enable DM&E to haul as many as 34 mile-long trains each day through the heart of Rochester at high speed, carrying coal and unspecified amounts of hazardous materials a few hundred yards from Mayo Clinic, Rochester Methodist Hospital, several nursing homes and other health- care facilities. The project threatens Mayo Clinic patients, many of whom are critically ill and unable to evacuate in the event of a DM&E derailment involving hazardous materials.

Specialized in: Track The Truth - Dakota Minnesota And Eastern Railroad
URL: http://www.dmetraintruth.com
Print press release      Bookmark this page
Related Press releases 
Jet Set Limousine Launches New Website To Better Serve Their Online Clients (Popularity: ): Miami, Florida, August 30, 2015- Jet Set Limousine, a premier provider of quality and reliable airport and wedding limousine service in Florida launched a new, modern website by utilizing new marketing strategies including Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and other campaigns.Located at jetsetlimoinc.com, the new website features the most reliable and luxurious chauffeurs shuttles in Miami, town car and airport limousine in Florida. Aside from this, the new website also includes ...
Shields Company Magnetic Sweepers Chosen by Dubai World Airports (Popularity: ): Ventura, CA - May 07, 2014 -- Shields Company Magnetics, a division of Shields Company Inc, the leading U.S. manufacturer of magnetic sweepers and industrial magnets, has been chosen by Dubai World Airports to assist in their F.O.D. safety and maintenance program.Shields Magnetics @ shieldscompany.com, has been selected by Dubai Airports to supply it's magnetic sweeper line for installation on ground support equipment in the region. Shields Company, through its ...
SII Launches New Automotive AEC-Q100 Qualified Voltage Detectors (Popularity: ): TOKYO, Dec. 18, 2012 -- Seiko Instruments Inc. (SII) announced on December 18 availability of the "S-19100" series voltage detectors rated for operation up to 125 degrees C. The new voltage detectors are certified to meet or exceed requirements of the AEC-Q100 automotive qualification standard.The "S-19100" Series was specifically designed for use in cars and other in-vehicle equipment. Typical applications include an engine ECU (Electronic Control unit), ABS (Antilock Braking ...
Mazda Announces SKYACTIV-D Clean Diesel Engine Program For New GRAND-AM GX Class (Popularity: ): DETROIT, June 2, 2012 -- Mazda Motorsports today announced that it will supply racing versions of its new SKYACTIV-D clean diesel engines to customer teams competing in GRAND-AM's new GX Class for advanced/clean technologies, beginning with the 2013 season."This opens a new chapter in racing for us," said Jay Amestoy, Vice President of Mazda Motorsports, Mazda North American Operations (MNAO). "We've won with rotary technology, and now we're looking to ...
Johnson Controls Reports Double-Digit Sales and Earnings Increases for 2010 Fourth Quarter; Affirms Forecast for Record Earnings in Fiscal 2011 (Popularity: ): Johnson Controls (NYSE: JCI) today reported double-digit increases in fiscal 2010 fourth quarter net sales and income. Highlights for the company's fourth quarter of 2010 include:Net sales of $9.0 billion vs. $7.9 billion in Q4 2009, up 15% Income from business segments of $604 million compared with $409 million a year ago Net income of $449 million vs. $300 million in Q4 2009 Diluted earnings per share of $0.66 vs. $0.47 last ...

Press release home snapshot 

Related Business 
Thursfield Smith - Transportation Consultancy (Popularity: ): A civil engineering and transportation consultancy specialising in rail, light rail and other transportation networks.
King Transportation Service, Inc. (Popularity: ): King Limousine and Transportation Service is a privately held, full service chauffeured transportation company founded in 1983. We are headquartered in the Philadelphia Tri-State area. We proudly own one of the largest fleets in the nation, being constantly ranked in the top 15 out of 10,000 limousine companies in the country.
The New York Museum of Transportation (Popularity: ): Located near Rochester, NY, the museum features trolleys, road and rail vehicles, photos, a large model railroad, and a research archive. Track car rides on a 2-mile railroad are run during the summer.
Ray's Transportation, Inc. (Popularity: ): Wholesaler of used railroad ties, relay rail, and other track material as well as scrap removal service provider to major rail companies.
Portec Rail Products, Inc. (Popularity: ): Provide rail lubrication and friction management systems for hi-rail, on-board and wayside application as well as insulated rail joints, rail anchors and other track accessories.
Domestic Container Transportation, Inc. (Popularity: ): Intermodal transportation provider, utilizing rail and truck.
Rochester and Genesee Valley Railroad Museum (Popularity: ): A joint project of the Rochester Chapter, NRHS, and the NY museum of Transportation. Located in Rush, NY.
Namibia Rail and Road Transport (Pty) Ltd (Popularity: ): Rail transport of bulk and containerised goods as well as transportation of passengers.
California Department of Transportation (Popularity: ): Caltrans is the state agency responsible for highway, bridge, and rail transportation planning, construction, and maintenance.
Exposing the Myth of Light Rail (Popularity: ): Includes news headlines, research papers, links, and letters from site visitors against light rail lines for public transportation.