S&P: All S&P 500 Index Mutual Funds Are Not Created Equal

Investors have put billions of dollars into vehicles that seek to track the S&P 500 index and logic would dictate that one S&P 500 index fund would be just like the next S&P 500 index fund. Logic would be wrong.

After screening for mutual funds that seek to track the S&P 500 index, S&P Equity Research found wide variances in the performance, costs, and risks of S&P 500 index funds. The S&P 500 index funds in S&P's mutual fund coverage universe have ranks covering the spectrum between five stars (18.8% of the 81 mutual funds in the S&P 500 Index Objective peer group) and one star (3.7%). The largest percentage of funds (45.7%) carried a three-star rank.

S&P mutual fund rankings are based, in part, on the prospects for the underlying holdings, and a fund is ranked positively, compared to similar funds, if it owns stocks that are deemed as undervalued based on S&P STARS and if they are high quality according to other Standard & Poor's proprietary analytical measures. But these inputs are of limited differentiating value when analyzing S&P 500 index mutual funds.

Over the past one- and three-year periods, the performance of the funds has varied more than one might expect. For the 12 months ended September 30, 2009, the top fund in the group, based on price change, declined 6.1%, while the worst performer dropped 9.3%. Meanwhile, the S&P 500 index actually dropped 9.4% over the same period. In contrast, the return of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY $105)) declined 6.9% over the same one-year period. SPY is ranked as overweight by S&P using a holdings-based methodology that is largely consistent with S&P's mutual fund approach. ETFs, which have become more popular in recent years, offer the benefit of low costs. Details on S&P Equity Research's ranking and commentary on SPY and other mutual funds and ETFs can be found on MarketScope Advisor®.

Among the highest ranked mutual funds in the group, we highlight three five-star funds: United Association S&P 500 Index Fund; II (UAIIX $7.80), Schwab S&P 500 Index Fund; Select (SWPPX $16.75), and Fidelity Spartan 500 Index Fund; Investor (FSMKX $74.25). All three funds outperformed peers over the trailing one-, three-, and five-year periods and did so incurring a comparable amount of volatility as measured by standard deviation, with expense ratios in line with or below the larger group. Neither UAIIX nor FSMKX has a sales load, but SWPPX has a redemption fee of 2%.

"As we continued to analyze our screen's results, we come across the most telling statistic - net expense ratio. Here, the range was extremely wide, especially when one considers that the funds' objectives are all the same - track the S&P 500 Index," said Dylan Cathers, an S&P Equity Analyst who helped develop S&P's new mutual fund ranking methodology. "The most expensive fund our screener found had an expense ratio of nearly 2.3%. That contrasts with the least expensive fund, which had a ratio of under 0.1%. When we break down these statistics further, we see that the average expense ratio for the four- and five-star funds was roughly 0.3%. In comparison, the net expense ratio for the SPDR S&P 500 ETF was slightly below 0.1%. In sharp contrast, the 17 two-star funds in our screen had an average of nearly 1.3%."

After looking more closely at the three one-star funds, we note that the all of them have trading histories of less than three years, for which they are penalized in our ranking methodology. (For details on the S&P Mutual Fund Methodology and nearly 20,000 reports.Also contributing to the low rank of these one-star funds, however, was their considerably above average expenses, which led to a negative cost factor score for each. Specifically, S&P 500 Capital Appreciation Fund; A (SSPAX $11.24) has a sales load of 5%, Wells Fargo Advantage Index Fund; A (WINAX) has a sales load of 5.75%, and Wells Fargo Advantage Index Fund; B (WINBX $38.99) had gross and net current expense ratios that were double the fund's peer averages.

"Given the differences between funds that have the same objective, mimic the performance of the S&P 500 index, we believe it is vital for investors to fully understand not just the relative performance of the funds they are investing in, but the risks and costs associated with those funds as well," Cathers said. "We note that investing in an ETF is certainly a valid alternative, as evidenced by SSPAX's investment philosophy - it has 100% of its assets in SPDR Trust; Series 1." The inclusion of costs make matching the performance of the index a challenge.

Standard & Poor's equity research, mutual fund, exchange-traded fund and bond research can be found on MarketScope® Advisor. More information on Standard & Poor's MarketScope Advisor is available by calling 1-877-219-1247. MarketScope Advisor is part of the Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services family of products. MarketScope Advisor provides financial advisors with actionable investment intelligence on multiple asset classes including stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, variable annuities, fixed income and workflow tools that enable advisors to stay connected to the market and their investments.

Standard & Poor's equity and fund research draws from the STARS coverage and Stock Reports, including detailed financial information, such as valuation models, sector and peer group analysis, and proprietary Standard & Poor's metrics such as Fair Value and Quality Rankings, on over 1,500 U.S.-listed equities, used by market professionals.

About Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services

As the world's largest producer of independent equity research, Standard & Poor's licenses its research to over 1,000 institutions for their investors and advisors. Standard & Poor's team of approximately 100 experienced U.S., European and Asian equity analysts use a fundamental, bottom-up approach to assess a global universe of approximately 2,000 equities across more than 120 industries worldwide. Follow Standard & Poor's equity analysts' U.S. market commentary each day at webste.

The equity research reports and recommendations provided by Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services are performed separately from any other analytic activity of Standard & Poor's. Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services has no access to non-public information received by other units of Standard & Poor's. Standard & Poor's does not trade for its own account. The analytical and ethical conduct of Standard & Poor's equity analysts is governed by the firm's Research Objectivity Policy, a copy of which may also be found at website.

About Standard & Poor's

Standard & Poor's, a subsidiary of The McGraw-Hill Companies (NYSE: MHP), is the world's foremost provider of independent credit ratings, indices, risk evaluation, investment research and data. With offices in 23 countries and markets, Standard & Poor's is an essential part of the world's financial infrastructure and has played a leading role for nearly 150 years in providing investors with the independent benchmarks they need to feel more confident about their investment and financial decisions.

For more information contact:
Marc Eiger, Communications, Tel.: 212-438-1280

This material is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security or other financial instrument. Securities, financial instruments or strategies mentioned herein may not be suitable for all investors.

All information provided by Standard & Poor's is impersonal and not tailored to the needs of any person, entity or group of persons. Standard & Poor's is not an investment advisor and Standard & Poor's and its affiliates do not sponsor, endorse, sell or promote any S&P index-based product. Standard & Poor's receives compensation in connection with licensing its indices to third parties. Indexes are unmanaged, statistical composites and their returns do not reflect payment of any sales charges or fees an investor would pay to purchase the securities it represents. Such costs would lower performance. It is not possible to invest directly in an index. Past performance is no indication of future results. Analytic services and products provided by Standard & Poor's are the result of separate activities designed to preserve the independence and objectivity of each analytic process. Standard & Poor's has established policies and procedures to maintain the confidentiality of non-public information received during each analytic process. Standard & Poor's and its affiliates provide a wide range of services to, or relating to, many organizations, including issuers of securities, investment advisers, broker-dealers, investment banks, other financial institutions and financial intermediaries, and accordingly may receive fees or other economic benefits from those organizations, including organizations whose securities or services they may recommend, rate, include in model portfolios, evaluate or otherwise address.