Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
           24 May, 2022

Category:  Press » Education


Ninth Circuit Court Rejects Arguments That Children's Religious School Tuition Should Be Tax Deductible

         Views: 1672
2008-12-13 05:17:39     
U.S. Department of Justice

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit today rejected taxpayers Michael and Marla Sklars' argument that they were entitled to claim deductions for tuition and fees paid to their children's Orthodox Jewish day schools, the Justice Department announced.

The Sklars sought charitable deductions under section 170 of the Internal Revenue Code for portions of their tuition payments made to the religious day schools their children attended, asserting that those portions of the tuition payments were for "intangible religious benefits." The Sklars made three arguments in support of their position, each of which was rejected by the Ninth Circuit.

First, the Sklars argued that their tuition and fee payments to exclusively religious schools were deductible under a "dual payment analysis" to the extent the payments exceeded the value of the secular education their children received. The Ninth Circuit rejected this argument, finding that the Sklars had not shown that the payment exceeded the fair market value of the benefit received for their payments (i.e., an education for their children), and they had not shown that any excess payment was made with the intent of making a gift.

Second, the Sklars argued that sections 170(f)(8) and 6115 of the Internal Revenue Code, as enacted in 1993, authorized the deduction of tuition payments for religious education made to exclusively religious schools. In dismissing this argument, the Ninth Circuit explained that the amendments to these tax sections referring to "intangible religious benefits" did not expand the types of payments for which charitable deductions were available, but rather merely created exceptions to the substantiation requirements added in those sections.

Third, the Sklars argued that denial of their claimed deductions violated the Establishment Clause of the United States Constitution, as well as principles of administrative consistency, because allegedly similar deductions were allowed for members of the Church of Scientology under a closing agreement with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The Ninth Circuit rejected these arguments as well, because "[t]o conclude otherwise would be tantamount to rewriting the Tax Code, disregarding Supreme Court precedent, only to reach a conclusion directly at odds with the Establishment Clause -- all in the name of the Establishment Clause."

"We are pleased that the IRS's denial of the Sklars' claimed deductions was upheld by the Tax Court and the Ninth Circuit," said Nathan J. Hochman, Assistant Attorney General of the Justice Department's Tax Division. "While taxpayers may choose to enroll their children in religious schools, the Tax Code should not subsidize this choice."

Assistant Attorney General Hochman thanked Tax Division attorneys Ellen DelSole and Kenneth Greene, who handled the case on appeal, as well as IRS Chief Counsel attorneys Henry Scheiderman and Keith Aqui who assisted them. He also thanked IRS Chief Counsel attorneys Louis Jack, Sherri Wilder and Julie Vandersluis, who handled the case in the U.S. Tax Court. More information about the Justice Department's Tax Division is available at www.usdoj.gov/tax/.

Specialized in: Ninth Circuit Court - Tuition - Tax Deductible
URL: http://www.usdoj.gov
Print press release      Bookmark this page
Related Press releases 
ASM Group of Institutes Introduces AWS Educate Cloud Computing Curricula in MBA/ PGDM in Emerging Technology (Popularity: ): Mumbai, INDIA – July 12, 2020: ASM Group of Institutes has announced that it will adopt cloud computing curricula from the Amazon Web Services (AWS) Educate global initiative into its mainstream college syllabus to help develop the next generation of cloud professionals. The cloud computing content from AWS Educate will be offered as part of PGDM in Emerging Technology by the ASM Group of Institutes programs starting in August, 2020.The ...
Prevent Blindness Offers New Educational Resources on Uveitis and Keratitis for Rare Disease Day (Popularity: ): CHICAGO - February 23, 2020 -- In observance of Rare Disease Day on Feb. 29, 2020, Prevent Blindness, the nation’s oldest volunteer eye health organization, is offering educational resources on uveitis, an inflammatory eye disease. Uveitis is a general term describing a group of inflammatory diseases that produces swelling and destroys eye tissues in the uvea (the middle layer of the eye that contains most blood vessels), according to the ...
Minnesota’s Best Colleges for 2017 Ranked by LearnHowToBecome.org (Popularity: ): San Francisco - March 18, 2017 -- LearnHowToBecome.org, a leading resource provider for higher education and career information, has analyzed more than a dozen metrics to rank Minnesota’s best universities and colleges for 2017. Of the 32 four-year schools on the list, Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Catherine University, Saint John’s University, University of Minnesota Twin Cities and The College of Saint Scholastica came in as the top five. 32 two-year ...
Inaugural Global CME Impact Award Winner Announced; AXDEV Group recognized for Continuing Medical Education Excellence and Innovation (Popularity: ): Denver, Colo. - February 10, 2017 -- Global Education Group (Global) and the Global Alliance for Medical Education (GAME) recently announced that AXDEV Group’s (AXDEV) “The European Performance Improvement in Diabetes Demonstration Project” (EPIDD) has received the inaugural Global CME Impact Award.Presented at the 42nd Annual Conference of the Alliance for Continuing Education in the Health Professions in San Francisco on Jan. 27, 2017, the Global CME Impact Award is ...
Student Survey of Competency-Based Assessment and Digital Badges Validates Soft Skills Bootcamp Development (Popularity: ): Vernon Hill, IL - October 01, 2016 -- Hundreds of postsecondary students volunteered for the opportunity to take Wonderlic's series of interactive, competency-based assessments for their specific program with the intent of earning digital badges, which demonstrate third party verification of their competencies.Seventy-five students who participated also responded to a subsequent survey. Their opinions reinforced the plans of the National Soft Skills Consortium that is developing a soft skills training ...

Press release home snapshot 

Related Business 
Ninth Judicial Circuit Court (Popularity: ): Find out about court functions or learn about pre-trial intervention, the expungement process, and the witness protection program; serves Charleston and Berkeley counties.
Property Tax Assessment Appeals (Popularity: ): Property Tax Assessment Appeals is the best way to minimize real estate tax and get the benefit on Property Tax Deductible. Contact with 1800 law firm to Appealing Property Tax Assessment and remove your all worries about property tax.
Private Home Tuition in Singapore (Popularity: ): Home Tuition Singapore is a professional tuition agency providing personalized home tutor matching service to families in Singapore. We believe in every child deserve to enjoy learning, unleash their full potential and success in life. We understand that with the limitation of current school learning environment, your children will hardly get the close 1 to 1 attention and learning program will never tailored base on your children progress.
Protest Property Taxes (Popularity: ): Make yourself smart and Lower Your Property Tax. Connect with 1800 law firm to Protest Property Taxes and use your rights to Reducing Property Taxes by using our easy and effective Property Tax Service. The Tax Tribunal is an administrative tax court. As the State's tax court the Tribunal has the authority over assessment disputes relating to both property and non-property tax matters.
Jackson County Legal News (Popularity: ): Lists births, deaths, real estate transactions, bankruptcies, circuit court filings, trail schedules, circuit court sentencings, divorces, and other public notices. Subscription required.
Maths Tuition Swindon (Popularity: ): Site offers professional tutoring and tuition in maths and english for children aged 6 - 16 within Wiltshire.Aspire Tuition was founded by experienced teachers, Andrea and David Parkinson. They, like many other teachers, recognised that the pressures of an overloaded curriculum, large class sizes and behaviour problems prevent many students achieving their full potential in school.
Oyez (Popularity: ): Database on major constitutional cases heard by the United States Supreme Court, with multimedia resources including digital audio of oral arguments and delivery of the Court's opinion.
Tax law controversies including criminal tax, collection tax, audit tax, and bankruptcy tax (Popularity: ): Former IRS Attorney does criminal tax, collection tax, audit tax, innocent spouse, offer in compromise, fraud cases, installment agreements and bankruptcy tax representation. Practice includes representation before the IRS and U.S. Tax Court and all other Federal Courts.
Tuition Singapore - Home Tuition Agency (Popularity: ): Home tuition is one of the best investments you are able to provide to your children mainly because it offers them a leg-up assisting them attain what you know they're able to accomplish.
East Court School (Ramsgate, UK) (Popularity: ): Residential school for eight to thirteen year old dyslexic children.