Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
           23 November, 2020


    
Category:  Press » Industry

 

Is Pluto A Planet? Astronomers Vote, JHU Takes Straw Poll

Popularity:
         Views: 1728
2006-08-19 06:44:58     
Johns Hopkins University

Generations of schoolchildren have memorized "My Very Energetic Mother Just Served Us Nine Pizzas" (or a variation thereof) in order to remember the order of the nine planets in our solar system. For 70 years - ever since it was discovered - the "p" in that oft-repeated mnemonic device has stood for Pluto, the ninth and smallest planet. But is Pluto actually a planet? Or is it something else? Astronomers have been debating this issue - often, hotly -- since Pluto’s discovery seven decades ago. That debate may finally end next week, when members of the International Astronomical Union meeting in Prague vote on a formal definition of the word "planet." According to the proposed definition, a planet is any star-orbiting object with enough mass for its own gravitational force to pull it into the shape of a ball. Furthermore, the object must orbit a star, without being a star itself. If the definition is adopted, Pluto would remain and our current nine-planet solar system would be joined by Ceres (the largest of the asteroids), Charon (Pluto’s largest moon), and 2003 UB313 (the provisional name for a recently discovered object larger and farther away from the sun than is Pluto). In addition, the IAU resolution also would establish a new "junior" class of planets called "plutons" to describe objects such as Pluto, which have less-than-circular orbits and take more than 200 years to orbit the sun. An informal poll of astronomers at the Henry A. Rowland Department of Physics and Astronomy at the Johns Hopkins University’s Krieger School of Arts and Sciences and the Johns Hopkins University’s Applied Physics Laboratory reveals that though _most_ favor Pluto’s continued existence as a planet and establishing a new definition of the word, the notion of a "pluton" is less well-received. Here is a sampling: * Karl Glazebrook, professor in the Department of Physics and Astronomy: "My take is that a physical definition like the one proposed makes sense: something large enough to be spherical and which is not a satellite. But if I were in charge, I would insist on a diameter of greater than 1,000 kilometers to define a ’planet’ in order to remove Ceres from the list. But that would be an arbitrary cut to preserve the order of the main nine and to save the hassle of rewriting textbooks. … Definitions and naming really matter little physically, anyway." * William P. Blair, research professor in the Department of Physics and Astronomy and chief of observatory operations for NASA’s Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer Satellite, operated by JHU: "This is really not a burning issue for most astronomers. It really is a ’classification’ problem more than an issue of science. … From what I can tell, they have tried to come up with a consistent definition: an object roughly spherical under its own gravity, orbiting a star, and not orbiting something else. OK, so far. Then they are apparently willing to immediately bend this relatively simple definition and allow Charon to itself be called a planet, with Pluto and Charon being a ’double planet’ system. This goes too far and seems inconsistent to me." * Richard Conn Henry, professor in the Department of Physics and Astronomy: "I think the notion that Pluto is a planet is absurd. When it was initially discovered, it was thought to be vastly more massive than it turned out to be. Its orbit is radically different from that of all the other planets. Down with Pluto, is what I say!" * Harold A. Weaver Jr., project scientist, Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory: "Personally, I’m in favor of the resolution, mainly because it’s about time we had a formal definition of the word ’planet,’ and the proposed definition is relatively straightforward. However, we must not forget that any attempts by us to pigeonhole objects in the universe are bound to have shortcomings. The classification schemes that we invent help us to place diverse objects in context, but we must also recognize that nature often doesn’t adhere to our attempts to categorize things. Although a ’planet,’ Pluto has more in common with the horde of ’Kuiper belt objects’ on the outskirts of our solar system than it does with, say, Jupiter. On the other hand, to those who complain that Pluto doesn’t deserve to be in the company of planets like Jupiter, I point out that there are also huge differences between Jupiter and Earth, for example. In any case, I doubt that the IAU could come up with a resolution that would please everyone." *Andy Cheng, Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory: "Yes, keeping Pluto as a planet is the correct decision. However, the new definition of planet does not work for me, because ’hydrostatic equilibrium’ is an idealization -- it is approximately correct for planets like Earth but is not exact. There is still no criterion for deciding how far from hydrostatic equilibrium an object can be and still qualify as a planet. Much of the science of geophysics deals with the different ways, and the reasons why, planets are not quite in hydrostatic equilibrium. Also the suggested term ’pluton’ is a bad idea, in my opinion."

Specialized in: Pluto - Planet - Astronomers Vote - Jhu - Straw Poll
URL: http://www.jhu.edu
Print press release      Bookmark this page
Related Press releases 
MDSi Expands Its Leadership Team (Popularity: ): ALPHARETTA, Ga. - November 18, 2017 -- MDSi, announces their appointment of several key leadership team members strategically selected to position MDSi for future success. MDSi’s goal is to “stay ahead of the curve” from a technology perspective and hire the right leadership team members to drive the overall product and professional services portfolio.“We are beyond excited about our future and exceptional talent joining the MDSi team. This additional leadership ...
Ulatus Launches Website Localization Services to help Global Businesses tap Local Markets (Popularity: ): May 9, 2017, NEW YORK: Ulatus, one of the leading translation service providers worldwide, launched its Website Localization solution to help global organizations expand their local presence and deliver digital content in a localized manner. Ulatus has been the quintessential language service provider connecting businesses across the globe and helping them break language barriers for over a decade. With a vibrant design and befitting motto, ‘Global in spirit, local at ...
Ulatus Launches Academic Translation Services for Researchers in China (Popularity: ): February 22, 2017, BEIJING: Ulatus, one of the leading translation service providers worldwide, officially announced the launch of its translation services in China for native researchers, academicians and corporates to enable them to communicate with their global counterparts in their language. Ulatus strongly believes that language barriers should not obstruct free flow of knowledge and ideas. With this launch, Ulatus strengthens its support to Chinese academicians in overcoming this barrier ...
Steve LaMotta Joins HR Tech Advisor as Chief Collaborator (Popularity: ): West Chester, PA - January 27, 2017 -- HR Tech Advisor is proud to announce recently signing on Steve LaMotta as Chief Collaborator.When asked about his new role, LaMotta had a lot of passion to share: "I've spent many years as a leader at #SHRM, #EMA, #DallasHR, #HRBoardroom, #HCI, and #TalentManagement, during which I have witnessed partnerships being treated all too often as a simple "check box" for winning more ...
Pan Gulf Products Launches Brand New Website (Popularity: ): April, 2014 - Saudi Arabia -- After winning the heart of thousands of customers all across the Saudi Arabia and the GCC, the company, Pan Gulf Products has come up with a brand new website to cater the needs of online customers. They have empowered their new website with state-of-the-art design and the latest features in the arena of web designing, which will provide their online customers an absolutely wonderful ...

Press release home snapshot 


Related Business 
Hopkins Ultraviolet Telescope (Popularity: ): A project of Johns Hopkins University, HUT was conceived, designed, and built by astronomers and engineers at JHU to perform astronomical observations in the far-ultraviolet portion of the electromagnetic spectrum, wavelengths of light that are inaccessible to ground-based telescopes.
BigPulse Opinion Poll (Popularity: ): The hot issues opinion poll for activist groups, public interest groups, individuals, organizations and political parties. Vote daily on social, political and environmental issues.
Megadeth-The Realms Of Death (Popularity: ): Contains images, band member tree, lyrics interpretations, timeline and a vote poll
I Am Gonna Copy (Popularity: ): Poll to vote on the proposition that everything that can be copied should be free, with no copyright and no intellectual property. Also includes links to articles and opinions.
JensonF1.com (Popularity: ): Offers news and features plus hundreds of photos, a forum, vote poll, quotes section and a large career profile.
Hectic Planet (Popularity: ): Collection of humorous and weird stories. Vote for your favorite and submit your own.
Changing Name By Deed Poll (Popularity: ): British Deed Poll Service specialise in Name Change by Deed Poll, Depoll & Changing Name After Marriage. If your looking for a safe, fast and cost effective Deed Poll Name Change, contact British Deed Poll Service, Changing Name by Deed Poll has never been so easy.
The Last Straw (Popularity: ): This reader-written journal of straw-bale and natural building provides information on construction techniques, projects, research/testing/code issues, and resources.
Ladies Straw Hats Shop (Popularity: ): Ladies Straw Hats Store - Largest Ladies Straw Hats Online Collection.
DSA Architects (Popularity: ): Straw bale research and testing, and has contributed important structural and detailing elements to the evolving straw bale vernacular.